How environmentally friendly are electric cars?

July 4, 2012 6:30 AM4 comments Author:

Tesla Model S Electric Car

As anyone who tries to keep up with current affairs will already know, one of the biggest challenges facing the planet is that of climate change. There is an overwhelming scientific consensus that the activities of humankind have a major bearing on changes in climate – even if this continues to be disputed in some quarters. Although governments, each pursuing their own individual agendas, have struggled to reach an agreement as to how to tackle the problem, individuals have increasingly been encouraged to find ways of reducing their own carbon footprint, effectively taking the lead in tackling climate change.

One technology which has been singled out as a key hope for the future is the electric car. What many people don’t realise is that electric cars aren’t actually anything new – they achieved some degree of popularity around the turn of the 20th century before being overtaken by petrol-fuelled cars – but advances in technology and the pressing need to tackle climate change have given the idea of switching to electric cars renewed momentum. Of course, the combined effects of high oil prices and fuel duty have long hit motorists hard in the pocket, so electric cars could potentially help drivers save money in the long run – but it’s well worth looking at just how eco-friendly these vehicles really are.

In contrast with conventional internal combustion engines, electric cars have a far lower impact in terms of air pollution. Unlike petrol and diesel-fuelled cars, they do not produce exhaust emissions, which pump pollutants into the atmosphere. In addition, the process of extracting fossil fuels from the ground is itself harmful to the environment – as the Deepwater Horizon disaster of 2010 made perfectly clear. Indeed, oil spillages are relatively commonplace in many parts of the world, but as many of these happen in developing countries, they are frequently overlooked by large sections of the western media. What’s more, it’s also been argued that high oil prices have a negative impact on the economic development of poorer countries by disrupting their balance of payments.

In addition, internal combustion engines are relatively inefficient at converting fuel energy into propulsion, with much of the energy being lost in the form of heat. Electric engines, on the other hand, are generally more efficient at utilising stored energy, and do not consume energy at all when coasting or resting. Furthermore, regenerative braking captures up to one-fifth of the energy wasted through braking, enabling it to be reused.


Francis Lawson is a freelance writer who enjoys writing about cars and has become a dab hand at finding the best car finance deals and discovering how to get UK car credit

Pinterest
Tags:
  • Colin

    While emissions from the vehicle are lower, the power has to come from somewhere. If that somewhere uses coal, then the environmental impact of the EV is worse than the gasoline-powered car, not better. There is also the environmental cost of building the car, in particular the battery. Modern batteries use some fairly toxic materials in their manufacturing process. Another factor that needs to be considered is the eventual disposal of the battery, as they have a limited number of charge/discharge cycles, with a lifespan shorter than the useful life of the rest of the car. These factors make EVs less environmentally-friendly than most people would think, and are factors that this article utterly fails to address.

    • Paul Scott

      Colin, the beauty of electric cars is that they allow you to drive pollution-free. If you are concerned about pollution from coal or natural gas in the generation of your electricity, and you should be, then you should not be using that dirty electricity to run your house. Many EV drivers use solar energy to power their homes and cars. Any real environmentalist should already be using renewable energy to run their home. Either install solar, or sign up for your utility’s renewable energy program. Once your home is using renewable energy, then your EV will, too. This one step will eliminate 100% of the pollution associated with your driving.

      The manufacturing process in building an EV is no more harmful to the environment than making an internal combustion car. The batteries in today’s EVs are lithium ion derivatives. Lithium is abundant and much less harmful to the environment in its extraction than oil.

      We’ve never fought a war over lithium or electricity, and we never will.

      The batteries will be used for energy storage after they are no longer useful in the car. After many years use for that purpose, the lithium and other elements will be recycled into new batteries.

  • Sandra Cameron

    We are also not taking into account the effect of electromagnetic radiation on the bodies of the people in the car. The batteries are not shielded. Sensitive people get very ill in these cars. Until they start shielding the batteries, it is best not to sit in them.

    • Paul Scott

      Sandra, I’ve been driving an EV for 10 years now. I used to drive an Toyota RAV4 EV and we would get this question about EMF all the time, so we acquired a device used to measure EMF and several of us sat in a RAV and turned it on. The needle on the gauge barely moved. Then, we got in a run of the mill Buick. We turned it on and the needle jumped almost all the way to the red zone. The RAV’s electronics, the battery and the motor, were shielded from EMF. The Buick’s alternator was giving off a lot of EMF and it was not shielded.

      I have tested the LEAF and the Volt for EMF and during acceleration and braking, both are within safe parameters. I would bet good money that the car you are driving is giving off a lot of EMF every time you drive it, and you don’t even know it’s happening.

      If you are driving an internal combustion vehicle, you are definitely polluting the air, water and land. And your money is going to the oil companies who are using it to control Congress. Some of your money is making its way to the Saudis who funnel money to the Taliban who then use it to kill our soldiers.

      There are much worse issues than EMF and you are complicit in all of them when you drive on oil.